Again, if you want to argue about what is written in that thread then argue about it there. Bringing your disagreements into this thread is against the rules.
As far as what makes sense to you to do. That's great, do what you consider the best way for you. No one wants to take that option away from you. I don't care what you consider to be the next logical request people may or may not make. That is not what this request is about.
The crux of the matter is I don't like a system that won't allow me to gain xp towards fate points if I decide I want to play a maxed destiny in challenging content.