I just want to make sure you guys know that it needs to go away for FvS as well. As I just had the nightmarish thought that you didn't hear as many FvS players hating on it so you might leave it for FvS and replace it with Warpriest only for Cleric. Make No mistake FvS needs a melee oriented PrE (warpriest) just as much as clerics do. And for the sake of being able to sleep at night can you let us know that FvS's also get Warpriest to replace the awful protector?
BTW Wow I can't think of a character in my stable of 14 now 16 Alts that would use ANY Protector ability besides Divine Might and The +6 elemental resists... that's how bad that tree is. It's not just that it's overly defensive... it's that the defensive you put in their is woefully underpowered compared to anything else... Even the bad Pali trees and Bard trees are better.