Be careful what you say and how you say, especially when you add lib details. It come back and bite you...
Could always make the base 10 SR from Drow stackable with items, if the total is superior to base. That'd up the maximum possible to 40, with Epic Mirror Cloak. If that's not enough, could also add the +10 base from Monk Diamond Soul as well, upping it to 50.
That should still be in acceptable ranges, especially for an ability that doesn't affect damaging spells and abilities.
Just remove Drow since they are usually dead anyway?
I kid...but yeah in PnP DnD...SR also effected your allies spells. Aka lets say you "resist" a heal...well then you die.
On that note...how come Halfling weapons don't count as a size category SMALLER? I know the answer...I am just pointing out how inconsistent it is.
Bacab Warforged 18 Arty (Active) Hjealer Dwarven Battle Cleric 10CLR/1FTR
Atropine Human 11 WIZ/1ROG (Active)
Member of THACO on Ghallanda
As has been stated for like 4 years Drow had THE most ridiculous set of enhancements for Spell Resistance
For ONE AP you could have SR 11
For TWO MORE (3) you could have SR 12
for THREE MORE (total 6?) You could have SR ... wait for it 13...
Do I need to continue...? If you spent 4 more AP's you could get it up to a whopping 14.
I think this is the most ridiculous thing that has ever been in DDO.
Now they get 10 + Level, as most people know. which is pretty good..
Why not give them an AP LINE FOR SPELL RESISTANCE AND PENETRATION?
1 AP for 1 additional SR, (i.e. 31 at lvl 20), 2 more for an additional and so on
Same with Spell Penetration...drow should have a racial line that stacks giving them an additional +1, +2, +3 to Spell Penetration for the appropriate AP cost.
I dont think its any big mystery that the Devs have caved in on WAY too many things as according to some annoying loudmouthed power gamers who haunt the forums day in and day out. Another perfect example is how Monk Ocean stance lost its bonus to AC while Tumbling. I mean WHAT??? Just because a few ignorant loudmouths stated over and over how tumbling was useless they go ahead and change it to a +3 dodge bonus? Excuse me I among others I know used the +12 AC from ocean stance EXTENSIVELY...
Its nauseating to say the least that a few ignorant morons can actually have some impact on the decision making of the developers.
Advocating repeated nerfs in the name of "balancing the game" then complaining about how DDO is moving away from D&D, is a direct contradiction in logic - D&D 3.5 (what DDO is based on) is not a balanced game. We can either have a balanced clone MMO with homogenized classes, or we can have a D&D game. We cant have both.
Perhaps having SR stack with items would be a little too much, although an useful SR vs epic is desirable: not 100% immunity, but say a nice 50% chance at least.
One possible way would be to add enhancements to drow that boost their innate SR by a fixed amount:
- Improved Drow Spell Resistance: +5 (1 AP)
- Greater Drow Spell Resistance +5 (2 AP) (total +10)
- Resilient Drow Spell Resistance (4 AP) Forces a spell resistance check before something can dispel or disjunction you
Ok, so the last one may be too much but still, a little something wouldn't be bad, they need a small boost to be honest, and SR seems a good place to start. Replacing the horrible dragon mark and the cleric prestige spell with something worthwhile would also be nice.
Devs: Thanks for making Druids available to VIPs without the pack. This more than anything, has made me want to buy the pack.
i think rather then improve drow sr, we should improve all sr.. i mean sr are basically useless.. 30 sr is like nothing at end game..
Another option for "stacking" SR would be to require 2 SR checks when casting a spell at a drow with a SR equipment; or 3 for a SR-geared drow monk.
Could that help?
personally I think SR should affect damaging spells as well, not completely negating them since that would be overpowered but perhaps making it a percentage to decrease damage, so sr30 would decrease damaging spells by 30%
<-Curelite Bottling Company->
Originally Posted by Chilldude
I like the multiple sr checks thing: 1 for drow, 1 for monk, 1 for items/spells
With the new expansion coming with a very heavy drow content it would sure be nice to revisit this and upgrade the SR for Drow and start letting it stack. Drow should have significant and useful SR over other races. It continues to be annoying in raids when every other race has virtually the same SR as a drow with one simple aoe spell effect. Now after playing through 7 lives on the same drow I can definately say that the SR is useful as you level, but once you hit 20 and run epics it loses most of its glamor. Maybe you can't stack all SR but one type of SR stacks with a drow's innate SR. Would 55 SR really be game breaking? I think not and it would provide both a realistic flavor of what epic drow (and heck even the witch doctor drow from the cannith challenges) SR should be. Shouldn't PC drow at least play SOMEWHAT like the drow in game? When they brough out Horcs they certainly added a ton of useful bonuses for both flavor and in game benefit. Time to give the drow what they always had in pnp and what the npc drow in game have now.
1: it would be overpowering depending on the circumstances, it would be the difference between getting several different types of cc spells tossed against you, or being almost immune to them. a CR 36 'epic' caster will only be able to bypass the SR on a 20, since npc/mobs do not utilize spell penetration gear/feat/enhancements, it would be extremely powerful at times.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not opposed to increasing drow spell reistance, but not just letting it flat out stack, special/specific gear, or enhancements, that increase it by a few points, would be as far as I would like to see it go. Think off a +5 to existing spell resistance being added to some named items or a 4 tier enhancement (2 points per tier) that increases their innate SR by 2 points each.
Drow, as we play them, already are 'somewhat like the drow in game', compare them to the drow in monastary of the scorpion, and you have pretty much the same spell resistance, but you're trying to compare them to 'epic' drow, which are 16 levels HIGHER then you are, which is like comparing a cub to a lion, they are the same, but one is much 'younger' and thus you can't compare them properly.
Last edited by Forgeborn; 02-10-2012 at 04:28 AM.
Drow gets 50% SR
Monk gets 50% SR
ePhiarlain Mirror Cloak gets 50% SR
Spell Resistance (cleric/FvS spell) gets 40% SR
Spell resistance on gear gets 20-30% SR
You could even allow it to stack, like WF Innate Fortification.
That would make Drow actually worth playing.
The Best Server: Gallhanda
Looking for a great guild? Check Out Our Guild: http://www.oldtimersguild.com/vb/forum.php
Looking for some good builds to play? https://www.ddo.com/forums/showthrea...for-Characters
Be careful what you wish for - there will probably be a lot of drow in the coming content. Do you really want them all to have a high spell resistance?
Epic drow already have ridiculously high SR, don't they? How much more ridiculous could they possibly get under this proposed new system?
[Famous last words...]
50% might be a little too high; what about just turning SR into percent chance directly? Thus lvl 20 drow & monks have a 30% chance of resisting spells; still seems like a pretty big advantage to me. But then what does Spell Penetration do if you revamp SR in this way?
An 11 SR at level 1 or a 30 SR at level 20 is a 50% chance to resist a spell from an equal level caster. Making this a straight 50% modifier is only a concern/benefit when dealing with vastly differing levels. Another way they could fix this is to make CR 36 caster mobs and CR36 drow mobs still have 20 or even 25 "Character levels" or "Hit Dice" concepts that have almost completely disappeared in DDO, and are hugely hindering where they haven't (Turn Undead, for instance)
This form's session has expired. You need to reload the page.Reload