View Full Version : GM of Flowers: Perfection of Mind(3/3) fails on a 1 roll

07-27-2012, 06:48 AM
I gathered a couple kobold shamans in Butcher's Path on Hard and let them spam me with spells. Even with Perfection of Mind at level 3, rolling a 1 against their Hold Person was still a failure. It should be safe to assume their spells don't have 43+ save DC meaning the "no automatic failure on a 1" feature wasn't working.


07-27-2012, 07:20 AM
I should have checked Perfection of Body as well before the first post...

Boneshrieker savants in Path to Madness on Elite with the same character as above. Perfection of Body at level 3 fails to save on a 1 fortitude roll. Similar to before, I'm going to assume the savants' Sound Burst in a level 8 quest don't have 40+ save DC.


Perfection of Soul's missing save bonus and broken "no automatic failure on a 1" feature has already been documented so I'm not going to bother checking that one.

08-10-2012, 08:49 PM
And I can confirm that Perfection of Soul (The Reflex one) is also bugged still.

No + 6 to reflex saves
Still fails on a roll of a 1

Which is an absolute shame, as I've been waiting for this for a while now. :)


08-18-2012, 07:55 AM
So update 15 is going live on Monday and there has still been no revision of this by the devs? I didn't expect much really, I thought these abilities would be another thing that takes months to get fixed... but when it is stated in the release notes that they are fixed and they actually aren't (I checked again 5 minutes ago to make sure), I have to wonder who compiles these notes and where Turbines testing is.


I should also add, as J1NG said, the +6 bonus to reflex is missing as well. Complete waste of destiny points at the moment.

08-20-2012, 04:15 PM
As of Update 15 currently on the live servers, fortitude, reflex, and will saving rolls all fail on 1s despite having the corresponding "Perfection of X" ability at rank 3. Like before, I tested in low level content so beating the offending spells' save DCs with a 1 shouldn't be an issue. Perfection of Soul is still missing the reflex save bonus while the other two appear fine in this regard.

In short, nothing changed despite what the U15 release notes say.

10-14-2012, 09:42 PM
Is this working properly yet or is it still broke?

Patch 15.1 says it was fixed, but have yet to see any player confirmation either way.

10-15-2012, 09:05 AM
Is this working properly yet or is it still broke?

Patch 15.1 says it was fixed, but have yet to see any player confirmation either way.

As far as I can remember (mid TR atm so can't check right now), it is mostly fixed. The only still bugged part is Perfection of Soul still not giving +6 reflex, but at least it stops you failing on a 1.